Jason Segel Told Me Why Jimmy Breaking The News To Alice About The Drunk Driver Is The Perfect Example Of How Shrinking Balances Comedy And Drama
Sometimes, tragedy and comedy work perfectly together.
Spoilers for Shrinking Season 2 are ahead. If you aren’t caught up, you can stream the series with an Apple TV+ subscription.
There’s no easy way to talk about death, and Shrinking Season 2 really hones in on that point. While the first season was about Jimmy finding himself again after the death of his wife, the sophomore season introduces us to the drunk driver who killed her, presenting a whole new set of challenges for Jason Segel’s character, especially when it comes to telling his daughter Alice about it all.
Of course, in a real Shrinking way, Jimmy breaks the news that the driver showed up at his office to his daughter in a surprisingly funny way, making for a great scene in the series. So, when I had the chance to chat with Jason Segel about his project on the 2024 TV schedule and this big moment between the father and daughter, he told me why it’s a great example of how the show balances comedy and drama, saying:
Life is clumsy, and this scene illustrates that perfectly and hilariously.
After spending the first half of the episode stressing about how to tell Alice that the drunk driver who killed her mom (who is played by Shrinking’s co-creator Brett Goldstein) came to his office, eventually he works up the courage. However, it's at an incredibly poorly timed moment as Lukita Maxwell’s character was celebrating passing her driver’s test when he broached the subject of their dead loved one. The conversation went like this:
Jimmy: Speaking of cars, do you remember what happened to your mom in one? Oh goddammit, goddammit!
Alice: What?
CINEMABLEND NEWSLETTER
Your Daily Blend of Entertainment News
Jimmy: I’m sorry. I’ve been trying to find a way in. That was not it. Sweetie, the other driver from your mom’s accident came to my office.
Then, the scene ends with Derek piping up from his balcony to poke fun at Jimmy asking “Speaking of cars?” To which Jimmy jumps up and down and throws a tantrum about his neighbor spying on him.
Overall, this whole situation is equal parts funny and tragic, and that’s kind of Shrinking’s whole thing. Segel elaborated on that point further, saying:
The Shrinking cast is made up of brilliant dramatic and comedic actors, and they’re able to handle issues like death, grief, medical issues, family drama, marriage and more with humor and heart.
At first glance, you wouldn't expect a show whose main characters deal with things like death, grief, Parkinson's and PTSD to be funny. However, Shrinking is genuinely one of the funniest on TV right now, because it leans into the natural clumsiness of life.
It’s a hard balancing act to pull off moments like the one Segel and I talked about, but it makes for an amazing product – which is probably why Shrinking was just renewed for a third season and is considered one of Apple TV+’s best shows.
Now, it’ll be interesting to see how Jimmy and Alice continue to navigate through the grief of losing their loved one while also dealing with the driver who hit her. To see how that plays out, you can stream new episodes of Shrinking every Wednesday on Apple TV+.
Riley Utley is the Weekend Editor at CinemaBlend. She has written for national publications as well as daily and alt-weekly newspapers in Spokane, Washington, Syracuse, New York and Charleston, South Carolina. She graduated with her master’s degree in arts journalism and communications from the Newhouse School at Syracuse University. Since joining the CB team she has covered numerous TV shows and movies -- including her personal favorite shows Ted Lasso and The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel. She also has followed and consistently written about everything from Taylor Swift to Fire Country, and she's enjoyed every second of it.
Harry Potter's James And Oliver Philips Had Fun Revisiting Some Filming Locations For Their New Baking Show, But The Best Moment From This Came From A Megafan: 'Literally Shaking'
Marissa Bode And Ethan Slater Tell Us The Wicked Song They Can’t Get Out Of Their Heads, And It's Not The One I Would Have Guessed