Why William Shatner Allegedly Blocked Kirstie Alley From Returning For Star Trek 3, According To A Trek Documentarian

Space may be the final frontier in the Star Trek world, but apparently earthbound grudges can still travel quite keenly through the vastness of space. Icons Unearthed director Brian Volk-Weiss knows that firsthand, as an interview he conducted for another project involving Gene Roddenberry’s “Wagon Train to the stars” saw Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan’s Kirstie Alley tell a story about how William Shatner allegedly blocked her from returning for the next film in the series that gave us some of the best sci-fi movies.

William Shatner’s Alleged Reason For Blocking Kirstie Alley From Star Trek III

While I sat down with Volk-Weiss to discuss Icons Unearthed: James Bond, which is currently airing Wednesday nights on Vice, our talk hinged on one fact he held dear when it came to his work. As it turns out, he prides himself on getting the stories that you’d be more likely to hear at conventions rather than through official studio produced featurettes.

A prime example of that happening on this new run of 007 stories was, in Brian Volk-Weiss’ recollection, a wild interview with George Lazenby. However, the director/producer also made the History Channel series The Center Seat: 55 Years of Star Trek, which chronicled the property’s place in pop culture. 

So when it came to stories too hot for Starfleet, Brian shared a couple of those stories with CinemaBlend, which is where Kirstie Alley’s supposed Star Trek sendoff came to be discussed: 

The story that the late Kirstie Alley shared with Brian Volk-Weiss expands upon the original narrative behind why Star Trek III: The Search for Spock recast Lt. Savvik with actor Robin Curtis. As recalled by director Leonard Nimoy in his autobiography I Am Spock (via ScreenRant), the legendary sci-fi actor maintained the long held reason that Alley failed to return was the following: 

So if Ms. Alley’s wardrobe was so upsetting to Mr. Shatner, how’d she get away with it in the first place? Well, despite her role as a cool and logical Vulcan, Kirstie was a charming and beautiful human who played her own game to see how far she could push her look. That led to the gradual transformation that Brian Volk-Weiss, and some other Star Trek fans, may not have noticed until she pointed it out.

How Kirstie Alley Was Allowed To Push Her Star Trek II: The Wrath Of Khan Wardrobe

Elaborating on how he didn’t even notice that Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan kind of pulled the rug out from under fans, Volk-Weiss continued to share just how and why Kirstie Alley changed her look. Continuing to unravel this story, Icons Unearthed’s director provided these further details from his interview with Alley:

Admittedly, there was a lot riding on director Nicholas Meyer’s sequel, which led to even more wild Wrath of Khan stories. With happenings like Gene Roddenberry accidentally leaking Spock’s big death to the public, and the production’s jump from a TV movie to a theatrical release strategy, chaos reigned to a certain extent. 

So you can kind of see where Kirstie Alley would be able to get away with charming people into letting Lt. Savvik let her hair down, as well as walking around in a Starfleet standard issue bathrobe. It was a gambit that saw Alley supposedly priced out of any participation in the Star Trek universe’s future. If that’s true, then William Shatner’s outrage robbed the fans of what could have been an ongoing story that almost ended in a betrayal of the highest order. 

The Notable Absences Star Trek Sequels Saw As A Result

Both Star Trek III: The Search for Spock Star Trek IV: The Voyage Home saw Lt. Saavik returning through Robin Curtis’ performance, but the absence of Kirstie Alley had always stuck out with fans. This was only more pronounced as her star continued to rise thanks to one of Alley’s best movie and TV roles on Paramount’s hit sitcom Cheers. Which is probably why a potential third return for the character was considered by the time 1991’s Star Trek VI: The Undiscovered Country was written. 

While we eventually saw Kim Cattrall’s Lt. Valeris fill that role, the initial intent was to cast Saavik as the traitor on the Enterprise. Two big decisions shot that prospect down, according to Star Trek VI’s text commentary (via Wikipedia): Gene Roddenberry thought that the fandom would riot if Saavik was a traitor, and Cattrall didn’t want to just play the next iteration of that same character. 

Valeris was born from this perfect storm of elements, which ScreenRant also attributes to another salary dispute between Kirstie Alley and those in charge. It’s for certain that you don’t get a franchise like Star Trek to exist for almost 60 years without stories as juicy as these. Leave it to documentarians like Brian Volk-Weiss to find them as he puts together the series that dive deeper into the entertainment we love. 

Fans of the James Bond movies can learn more about the wild history that went into making them, as Icons Unearthed: James Bond continues to air on Wednesday nights, only on Vice. However, if you stick around, we’ll have some more details on stories of both Bond and Star Trek, as our interview with Brian Volk-Weis gave us even more to talk about on those twin fronts.