I would like to say there is no other movie quite like No One Will Save You — which is available to stream with a Hulu subscription — but that would not be entirely true. The otherwise inventive and thoroughly intense sci-fi flick that pits Kaitlyn Dever (in one of her best movies) against some invasive extraterrestrials can be rightfully compared to some other great horror movies currently available for home viewing.
Fair warning: not all of the titles that come to mind necessarily fall under the alien invasion film category. However, that particular genre is where we shall start in our guide to the movies we believe you should check out if writer and director Brian Duffield’s acclaimed thriller also worked for you.
The A Quiet Place Movies (2018-2024)
The human race is forced to live in complete silence in order to survive a world overrun with vicious aliens that use sound to detect their prey.
Why fans of No One Will Save You will like it: When it became apparent that dialogue was scarce (to put it lightly) in No One Will Save You, it immediately reminded me of the only other modern alien invasion movies I would liken to a silent film: director and star John Krasinski’s heart-wrenching nail biters, A Quiet Place and A Quiet Place Part II, and Michael Sarnoski's prequel, A Quiet Place: Day One.
Stream A Quiet Place on Paramount+.
Rent or buy A Quiet Place on Amazon.
Buy A Quiet Place on Blu-ray on Amazon.
Stream A Quiet Place Part II on Paramount+.
Rent or buy A Quiet Place Part II on Amazon.
Buy A Quiet Place Part II on Blu-ray on Amazon.
Rent or buy A Quiet Place: Day One on Amazon.
Signs (2002)
Startling evidence leads a widowed former minister (played by Mel Gibson) to suspect his family (and the world) are in danger from malevolent visitors.
Why fans of No One Will Save You will like it: One of the best M. Night Shyamalan movies, Signs, is a masterfully creepy alien invasion essential that, unlike No One Will Save You, takes its time with its relentless scares, but is like it in how it addresses moving on from tragedy.
Stream Signs on Max.
Rent or buy Signs on Amazon.
Buy Signs on Blu-ray on Amazon.
Nope (2022)
A horse wrangler (Academy Award winner Daniel Kaluuya) and his sister (Keke Palmer) try to capture evidence of a deadly, otherworldly phenomenon plaguing their desert town.
Why fans of No One Will Save You will like it: By the end of No One Will Save You, it is clear there is more than meets the eye to this alien movie on a symbolic level, which is exactly what fans would say about writer and director Jordan Peele’s Nope when citing why it is one of the best horror movies on Peacock at the moment.
Stream Nope on Starz.
Rent or buy Nope on Amazon.
Buy Nope on Blu-ray on Amazon.
The McPherson Tape (1989)
A family’s innocent birthday celebration in their isolated, woodland home is interrupted when some of them capture horrifying evidence that they are not alone.
Why fans of No One Will Save You will like it: No One Will Save You is certainly one of the more unique alien invasion movies of its time, which is what anyone who may have seen Dean Alioto’s cult favorite debut, The McPherson Tape (a.k.a. UFO Abduction), would have said about it when it came out, especially since found footage horror movies were pretty much unheard of then.
Stream The McPherson Tape on Tubi.
Stream The McPherson Tape on Pluto TV.
Rent or buy The McPherson Tape on Amazon.
Buy The McPherson Tape on Blu-ray on Amazon.
Prey (2022)
An aspiring, 18th-Century Commanche warrior (played by Amber Midthunder) puts her hunting skills to the ultimate test when she encounters a creature unlike anything Earth has ever seen.
Why fans of No One Will Save You will like it: Intriguingly, No One Will Save You is the second sci-fi horror movie about a young woman singlehandedly taking on an extra-terrestrial enemy released by Hulu in just the last couple years — the first being the stunning Predator prequel, Prey, from director Dan Trachtenberg.
Stream Prey on Hulu.
Buy Prey on Blu-ray on Amazon.
Skinamarink (2022)
Two young children wake up to discover that their parents are missing and any means to an exit from their house has mysteriously vanished.
Why fans of No One Will Save You will like it: When compared to this other highly experimental supernatural home invasion thriller that is light on dialogue, I would call No One Will Save You the more accessible, but Skinamarink — also available with a Shudder subscription — is still an amusing and unapologetically nightmarish game changer for indie horror that ensures first-time writer and director Kyle Edward Ball a bright (or, more accurately, dark) future.
Stream Skinamarink on Hulu.
Rent or buy Skinamarink on Amazon.
Buy Skinamarink on Blu-ray on Amazon.
The Strangers (2008)
A couple (Liv Tyler and Scott Speedman) staying the night at a vacation home in the middle of the woods must fight for their lives against a trio of masked uninvited guests.
Why fans of No One Will Save You will like it: Some might still consider writer and director Bryan Bertino’s The Strangers to be an even more disturbing example of a home invasion thriller than No One Will Save You because its plot — while only loosely based on a true story — incorporates a more frighteningly familiar enemy: humans.
Stream The Strangers on Max.
Rent or buy The Strangers on Amazon.
Buy The Strangers on Blu-ray on Amazon.
Underwater (2020)
A Marianna Trench drilling station crew struggle to find their way to the surface after suffering what they initially assume was an earthquake, until bizarre evidence points to the contrary.
Why fans of No One Will Save You will like it: Also one of Kristen Stewart’s best movies, director William Eubank’s claustrophobic gem Underwater bears very little resemblance to No One Will Save You in terms of its style and physical setting, but it is a creature feature co-written by Brian Duffield.
Rent or buy Underwater on Amazon.
Buy Underwater on Blu-ray on Amazon.
Love And Monsters (2020)
Years after a monstrous takeover drove what is left of humanity underground, a young man (played by Dylan O’Brien) risks life and limb to reunite with his long-lost girlfriend (played by Jessica Henwick).
Why fans of No One Will Save You will like it: Director Michael Matthews’ quirky, romantic, post-apocalyptic thriller, Love and Monsters has very little similarities to No One Will Save You in terms of its overall execution, save the fact that it involves young people contending with bizarre creatures and comes from the mind of co-writer Duffield.
Rent or buy Love and Monsters on Amazon.
Buy Love and Monsters on Blu-ray on Amazon.
Spontaneous (2020)
An unexpected romance develops between two high school seniors (Katherine Langford and Charlie Plummer) just as their peers begin to inexplicably start dying of spontaneous combustion.
Why fans of No One Will Save You will like it: This unfairly overlooked 2020 movie based on Aaron Starmer’s darkly humorous, romantic horror novel Spontaneous has less similarities to No One Will Save You than the previous two titles, but as Duffield’s debut as both a writer and director, it is a must for fans curious to explore his lighter side.
Stream Spontaneous on Pluto TV.
Rent or buy Spontaneous on Amazon.
Buy Spontaneous on Blu-ray on Amazon.
BONUS: Monsterland (2020)
A young waitress facing a dire moral dilemma, a business executive’s troubled past catching up with him, and a curmudgeon who finds something that is unlike any sea creature he has caught at the end of his fishing line are just some of the stories told in this anthology TV show of the horror variety.
Why fans of No One Will Save You will like it: Kaitlyn Dever was no stranger to spooky stuff before leading No One Will Save You, having appeared in three episodes of one of the best horror TV shows on Hulu, Monsterland, which also bears a deeper, underlying message beneath its fantasy elements.
You could go ahead and stream No One Will Save You on Hulu right now just to relive those same scares again, or you could continue the journey a bit further by popping in some of these somewhat similar favorites.
